Critical hits.

Nothing is more dramatic in D&D than rolling a critical hit. The die rolls a 20 and everyone gets all excited. The players picks up his damage dice,  grabbing extra dice ready roll that double damage. The player let's loose and rolls snake eyes. The lowest possible roll.

We decided this just wouldn't do. Our rule is the first damage die is always maximum. For example 6 on a D6. The second die is rolled as normal and added to the 6.

For example if the damage die was a D8 the player would roll 1D8+8 (plus any bonuses). No matter what that D8 rolls its exceptional, because even a roll of 1 is greater than the weapons normal maximum.

Comments

  1. Cross PlanesDecember 30, 2017 at 8:04 PM

    I like this and will steal it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gaming RoninJanuary 8, 2018 at 6:31 AM

      I really do feel like it's a better option all the way around. Nothing seems more disappointing to a player than a bad damage roll on a critical.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Light (Radiant) sword for 5E D&D

Image
A 10" to 12" cylinder (hilt) that when activated, projects a short beam of light that effortlessly cuts things. All damage done by the light sword does Radiant damage. These artifacts are relics from antiquity. Light swords were once used by Atlantian knights, very few survived into the modern age. Only 12 were known to survive the loss of the great city, but the exact number is more lore than history. The legend tells that 12 knights survived and made their way to the rest of the world. Scattered to the winds these knights wondered the world fighting injustice and attracting followers. A few founded orders but none would bend a knee to any kingdom or warlord, often bringing them at odds with powerful nations. The secrets of Atlantian magic and use of power sword combat was passed from Knight to apprentice for centuries. Rumor has it that one secret of Atlantian magic is the creation of light swords. As kaleb kess founder and leader of the order of the northern
Read more

Epic 6 style play for 5th edition D&D.

I really would like to come up with guidelines for playing D&D with epic 6. I'm toying with just running it with the basic set of rules for now, and possibly trying it to the full range of classes in the player's handbook at a later time. If you don't know what Epic 6 is, I'll link it here to a post I made about it elsewhere. Doing an Epic 6 version for 5E is tougher because when the concept came out 3E just gave more attacks, feats, and bonuses as characters leveled. But 5E has abilities and features above level 6 players really want. I would hate to take those abilities away. Even though just capping level is the easiest solution. If I choose to give noncasters their features I rightly need to give casters access to their higher level spells. Making the option of capping the character's level less appealing. One option I like is to allow characters to progress as normal but only stop progression on proficiency bonus at level 6 (8 or 10). In this sense 5E is
Read more

Sandbox vs railroad in role-playing games.

One topic that comes up especially in D&D circles is the railroad v.s. Sandbox styles of DMing. Most any time these terms are used it's to point out the superiority of one or the other. I would like to propose that not just are they both totally valid, they should be thought of as being useful together. My average game is a mix of both elements. I would like to better define what I mean by these two terms. whenever most people say a game or adventure is a railroad style game thy mean the game is set on a path. The plot is linear and travels from point to point without deviation, like a train on it's rails. The players talk to an NPC who sends them to a location, the location has clues that send the players to another location. Everything is planned out and the game moves along the points to advance the story. Most premade adventures and campaigns are railroad style games. A sandbox adventure on the other hand is an open world. The players are set down in it and can fol
Read more